Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

100% on mobile Web.

Firefox already on beta.

As for Edge it is already in development, and to be honest it doesn't matter with its insignificant market share.

When Microsoft employees use only Chrome at BUILD to show Azure and .NET Core MVC features, the writing is on the wall how relevant the browser is on the market.

Still you keep running away to clarify what "many browsers" means.

Maybe it is my lack of native English skills, but Edge being a single browser is far away from being "many browsers", even if we include Firefox until they get out of beta, two still does not make "many browsers".



> As for Edge it is already in development, and to be honest it doesn't matter with its insignificant market share.

Market shares are not the same across countries, clients or even industries. That's the first mistake you are making. If I develop a product, I target whatever browser my customers use, not some world wide statistic that has very little local significance.

You just don't get to ignore what goes against your point just to feel that you are winning an argument, that's childish.

> 100% on mobile Web.

Which is False, Firefox on Android doesn't support web components.

> Firefox already on beta.

Which doesn't matter if support has not shipped. "will ship" is not "has shipped". I am only interested in current support, as we speak, I was never talking about "will eventually ship" since I don't work with eventual features, obviously.


Firefox on mobile does not count for the majority of companies.

Mobile web is all about Safari and Chrome.

Again you keep avoiding to explain what "many browsers" means.


According to netmarketshare[0], on desktop[1], Edge currently has 3.8% market share, more than Safari and Opera together. Combining mobile+desktop Edge has 2%.

Edge cannot be ignored if one is serious about any kind of business: that's 3-4 out of every 100 desktop users (existing or potential customers), or 'just' 2/100 if one includes mobile.

— Honestly, it seems that you are trolling. But I post the above stats in case you are not. But I also back it up with my own personal 'anecdata': I build business-to-business ecommerce, in our specific market our users are primarily (>95%) using desktop browsers, we have many thousands of existing business relationships, we cannot mandate which browsers they use — we draw the line at having the site simply work in all "modern browsers", which obviously includes Edge.

It doesn't really matter whether it's "many browsers" that don't support Web Components, or whether it's just one major browser. For many businesses, choosing WC is simply not a viable option for the foreseeable future.

[0] No affiliation, just googled it. [1] https://netmarketshare.com/browser-market-share.aspx


You are reading it wrong, it is not me that mandates the browsers.

I have written already in multiple answers, it is the customers that decide which browsers should a given project support, by explicitly stating them on the project delivery contract.

So your customers care about EDGE, fine. Many don't.


> As for Edge it is already in development, and to be honest it doesn't matter with its insignificant market share.

Er, really? I use Edge. It's just what's standard on the Windows machine I bought. I can't imagine that it has insignificant market share...


Check how many BUILD 2018 videos presentations were done in Chrome and how many were using Edge.

As for actual market share, http://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share


Hm, maybe I missed the context somewhere along the lines. Are you talking about something on the developer side only? I thought the discussion was about something that works or not for the end user.


No, I mean the browsers that are part of accepting testing from project delivery contracts.

If it doesn't make the list, it is a nice to have only, in case someone on the team bothers with it.

Microsoft by using mostly Chrome at BUILD 2018 has given the sign to many businesses that it isn't worthwhile to list EDGE as a requirement.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: