Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I just don't get why people think that uploading all their passwords that are protecting some potentially extremely sensitive data to some random internet company is a good idea.

And then wonder when they are being extorted ("you better subscribe and pay or else!"), datamined (article) or have their data stolen (LastPass was hacked before).

People, stop giving these businesses the loaded guns to hold at your head! There are plenty of offline password managers that will do you equal or better service than this.



> There are plenty of offline password managers that will do you equal or better service than this

That's cool, I didn't know that and I'm eager to hear of replacements. I regularly use 5+ devices, currently all via 1password and have about 3 family members including myself using 1password (so in total maybe 10 devices or something like that). None of us want to host a server by ourselves (as both time and security is of a concern there). What do you suggest we use in my household? Would have to work on Windows, Linux, macOS, Android, iPhone, web and unix terminals. It should be able to store passwords, photos, credit cards and also have browser extensions for Safari, Firefox and Chrome for making it easy to fill out. + if it has a password generator as well, but not required.

Many thanks!


I am using KeepassXC and keeping the encrypted password file in a Google Drive, shared across my devices. That would likely cover most of your use cases too (the file is locally cached so even if there is no network connection I am not screwed).

For cases where you really can't use an offline password manager (e.g. because you are using some sort of gadget that doesn't allow you to connect to Google Drive or whatever), sync the relevant (not all!) passwords using your browser account.

Why is the above better than your 1password, LastPass or something else? Well, I don't need to take the company at their word that they are properly encrypting the file and properly protecting it - I know it is because it has been encrypted locally by Keepass (easy to check, the source code is all available too).

Google only ever gets to see a binary encrypted blob. And if I need to move to another service (e.g. I have been using Dropbox before), I simply move the file, that's all. No mess, no fuss. My data (especially passwords!) aren't held hostage anywhere.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: