Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>He wasn’t.

He was.

>Das Kapital was just a bad book in terms of economic theory regardless of its anthropological value.

Das Kapital is a great book in both economic and anthropologic terms.

>Economists tended to discard Marx long before Lenin.

No they didn't.

>Hm. I am not sure I understand the connection.

You should try reading Das Kapital.



Well, if you want to know opinion of his contemporaries you should read what they have written. Also, the third volume has a preface by Engels that tries to deflect criticism of contemporary economists.

> You should try reading Das Kapital.

Well, maybe you should try re-reading it, because as far as I understand it, it doesn’t say anything close to that; though I am sure there is an interpretation that claims so as there are dozens of various contradictory Marx’s interpretations.


Get some self awareness man, I was pointing out how combative without substance your comment was.

"No, you're wrong. That's not how it was."


What is asserted without evidence can be discarded without evidence.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: