> I believe the best way to make this work is by keeping the network itself in public hands and then having a competition of contributors to the network - e.g. electricity providers that add energy to the grid.
Even in that configuration, companies often have trouble fronting the money required to build a sizeable power production infrastructure. It can be seen in renewables, where investors build a lot of renewables production, but don't really care about what will happen once these renewables produce a large share of the network's power, and don't research and develop the missing pieces or the expertise to maintain.
You could argue that the public market regulator needs to better incentivize private companies to build the right thing, but at this point, the real value is the regulator's planification, not private companies buying and installing Chinese PV. So you have a capital-intensive private industry with little value-add.
> at this point, the real value is the regulator's planification
Exactly, in many of these markets a small team of public ally employed engineers could design a reasonable strategy in a week. Now you need a massive team of lawyers just to draft a contract with a private company that isn’t full of loopholes they are gonna abuse. Managing them is more work than doing the job directly. And government can always access cheaper loans
I'm assuming the main issue with government is that people keep electing politicians uninterested in statesmanship or running an administration, and with personal incentives to privatize.
I still don't understand how voters can choose to entrust public service to people that claim public service is inefficient: they can run it in the ground and claim "see, I told you!"...
Even in that configuration, companies often have trouble fronting the money required to build a sizeable power production infrastructure. It can be seen in renewables, where investors build a lot of renewables production, but don't really care about what will happen once these renewables produce a large share of the network's power, and don't research and develop the missing pieces or the expertise to maintain.
You could argue that the public market regulator needs to better incentivize private companies to build the right thing, but at this point, the real value is the regulator's planification, not private companies buying and installing Chinese PV. So you have a capital-intensive private industry with little value-add.