Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You make very interesting points, but I'm having some trouble understanding exactly what you mean.

When you say that at some point in time there will be a shortage, what do you mean, exactly? A shortage of what?

The way I understand capitalism is that shortages, in a sense, don't actually exist in free markets (except temporarily if there are unexpected disruptions), because capitalism is mostly a system of allocating the resources that are available, in the most efficient way that we know of.

Or another way of thinking about it, is that there is always a shortage of almost everything, because we could always take advantage of more resources if they were available.

So what do you mean exactly?



Resources are finite, they will eventually run out. All resources are finite except those that nature provides as part of its own sustainable cycle, everything else sooner or later comes to an end and the more of nature that we destroy the more we will have to provide ourselves. Resource availability has five stages: we don't have it because we can't get at it, we have access to it and we're actively getting it, getting it has become too expensive (you end up alternating between this one and the previous one for a while), we have to get it from our previous waste material because the original sources have all run out and finally we no longer have it in a form that we can get at it because it has become too dispersed.

Every resource that came as a gift with the 'bare' planet (before life began and exposed by various tectonic processes) follows these stages. So the more of nature we leave in one piece and the more we work in a sustainable manner (maximize recycling, for instance) the longer humanity will survive in a recognizable form. The only other way that I can think of is to go off-planet.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: