Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I am not sure where you got the impression of me talking about only "Steam games". Bottles allows you to run any Win32.

And besides that, "these threats are off in fantasy land" is an invalid defense in my opinion, considering the (quite sophisticated) XZ Utils backdoor happened not too long ago! Like I said, if such an attack towards X11 hasn't been deployed in the wild, it can only suggest such endeavor is unprofitable, not because the threats are fantastical.



XZ utils backdoor could have exploited X11, but didn't. And the most common Wayland configurations wouldn't have protected people from the backdoored utility; only extremely paranoid and therefore esoteric setups might have.


> And the most common Wayland configurations wouldn't have protected people from the backdoored utility

If the attacker decided to backdoor an utility and make use of X11, it is most likely the backdoored utility will listen to keyboard events, read the bitmaps of other X11 clients.

And there's nothing that can stop the backdoor from doing so on X11...

Anyways, if you are saying the Wayland security policies are unneeded because there hasn't been an attack on X11 (this is the fundamental disagreement between us), consider the following: You don't install doors in your premise, because there hasn't been a case of burglary in your neighborhood?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: