Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Just last month I bought a Blu-ray 4K player and several discs because of the extra features you get on the disc that don't seem to be available on streaming. For example, the disc for Coco, a movie I love dearly, has a feature about the film's Italian heritage among others.

("Film"? Yes. If anyone objects, I will "dial" my phone so we can discuss.)



Streaming platforms would do well to incorporate more bonus features into their releases.

OK, you sometimes get some trailers, promotional featurettes, etc. But nothing like the cool stuff I remember from the best DVD and Blu-ray discs. Interactive elements, themed menus, director & cast commentary tracks, deleted scenes, etc... I miss that stuff!


I have started building a UHD Blu-ray collection too now the price of discs has come down a little vs regular Blu-ray. They’re fantastic.

I have a new annoyance though: many new movies are offered in Dolby Vision on streaming services, but the UHD BD release is only HDR10. I saw a comment on Reddit from someone involved in the industry who said that the additional work in getting the different metadata in line on discs is often just skipped. On streaming they can just serve different files for all combinations of resolution and HDR offered.

It’s annoying because if I’m paying a premium to get the best-of-the-best option, I want it to actually be the best.


Regarding the Italian heritage, of course I was referring to another favorite of mine, Luca. D'oh!

Coco does have some great extra features about its Mexican heritage.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: