Unfortunately this can't be true, otherwise it wouldn't be a product of RLHF.

Go on an average college campus, and almost anyone can tell you when an essay was written with AI vs when it wasn't. Is this a skill issue? Are better prompters able to evade that innate immune response? Probably yes. But the revulsion is innate.

Crowds can have terrible taste, even if they're made up of people with good (or at least middling) taste