Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> X13: 60 seconds

If you know what you are doing, and have that spare part including the correct screwdriver and screws in the shelf next to your desk?

How often does your keyboard fail? I've never had that happen in all my computing life and the other parts are usually not that easy to change for any regular person on a laptop. Not sure if that's the scenario to optimize for.



I don't know the X13, but I have lots of experience with old Thinkpads. Keyboard replacement really used to be super easy:

Turn Laptop over, look for the screw holes with a keyboard icon next to it, remove those screws with a Phillips size 1 screwdriver, flip over, open lid, slide keyboard up and lift out, unclip flex cable, then do the reverse steps with the new keyboard.

After a while, Lenovo started using more clips and fewer screws and things started to go downhill from there.


For regular users with a consumer laptop, a damaged key or keyboard means:

Laptop defunct. Use an external keyboard if not affordable.

Used my X220 for ten years, handled it with care, but after ten years a new keyboard was a nice uplift. You can also switch languages but especially also the layout between ANSI- and ISO.

Buying an Apple device with ANSI in Europe? Pain. ThinkPads? Buy anything. 30 EUR and new keyboard.


So even after 10 years you didn’t need a new keyboard, you just wanted one? I think you’ve proved the GP’s point.


How many people use a laptop for ten years?


Er, exactly! Most people replace the entire machine within that time, so they still don’t need a replaceable keyboard. You’re now arguing with yourself.


I mean, the irony is that the keyboards most people associate with failing are the Apple ones (2015-2020).

... Which are nearly impossible to replace, and are what the modern Thinkpads are trying to emulate.

The old X13's would almost never fail, so replacing them was never a consideration.

(also, screws are not that annoying, but I agree with the rest, most companies aren't/weren't replacing keyboards on laptops)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: