Apple hardware is as good as it’s ever been, but macOS has seen better days. The fun of everything being scriptable, consistency throughout the system, and even stability has been replaced with transitional pains of a new application framework, iOS-ification of much of the system, and inconsistent behavior that I have trouble reasoning about, despite using Macs as my frontend almost exclusively for the past 20 years.
That being said, I bought an old Dell last year for dev work (primarily Linux) and I can’t believe most of the world puts up with Windows. It seems like desktop computing is an afterthought.
>MacOS has never been worse. However it has never been this much better than Windows.
This would explain my experience, long time users confuse me when they tell me how bad it is, and maybe they're right. Coming from windows (well a while ago) it's still so nice to use.
Mac OS 7 on my first macbook 28 years ago was pretty bad. But in general I agree. Also there are one or two nice features in the recent OS's like my phone can actually stay tethered to the laptop sometimes when I close the lid and reopen it later.
What issues do you face on windows? I use both Mac and windows daily and I can't say I entirely prefer one over the other, and in recent years I've run into more noticeable bugs on macOS (although it does look better)
Even on literally top of the line machines (Razer Blade 18, Ultra 9 275HX, 64G DDR5, NVMe over PCIE4, 240Hz display) the thing feels sluggish.
UI "quirks" such as hiding the context menu, taskbar being forced into place, and the removal of the "never combine" taskbar buttons are just gobsmacking.
Worse, Windows Pioneered "drag and drop" yet now we can't even drag and drop files or shortcuts onto taskbar icons.. a workflow I actually used a lot and which is still supported in MacOS.
The forced integration is also a non-starter. MacOS doesn't require online accounts, Apps (onedrive, Teams, Cortana et al) or force "suggestions" down my throat in the UI even though I am constantly told that Apple are the ones who force their ecosystem on me.
I don't believe that it did. MacOS 1 had drag and drop. You could always drag a document onto a program to open the document with that program. Also, notably, to eject a floppy disk permanently you dragged the floppy disk to the trash can.
As soon as I heard them say "We're finally able to make the UI that Apple Silicon enables because of its performance" I knew wholeheartedly that it was going to be an enormous performance thief.
I'm not touching 26 with a 10-foot-pole.
I will even avoid buying new Macbook laptops, even though I have an M2 Air and M5 is around the corner.
This sort of forced integration is exactly why I consider macOS a non-starter. The ARM chips are neat, but I'm only interested in daily-driving computers I can own.
Yeah, it's specifically Windows 11 that has this issue.
I'm not certain as to why, if I had to speculate it would be the new scheduler prefers the efficiency cores and then thrashes the L1/L2 cache as soon as there's any actual work to do in the operating system (IE; you clicked something) by putting it on a performance core.
Windows 11 performance seems to be less terrible on devices that don't have big.LITTLE architectures.
Explorer in Windows 11 was overhauled, and its address bar behaviour is now absolute garbage. For example, type a directory path into it and press enter - takes 10 seconds to display the contents of the directory. Auto-complete on the address-bar as you type is unusable as it is so slow it's quicker just to type out the entire path manually.
Oh - and the popup UI for volume level and WiFi (and bluetooth etc) causes the system to freeze up sometimes, when you open it.
Logging in and the mouse freezes up for multiple seconds.
I'm sure these are not universal to all machines running Windows 11, but for me it's an all together shoddy user experience, and I'm sure there's a few other headaches that I forgot to mention.
Yeah, fully agree - and I should say this is specifically for my travel laptop. I have a desktop PC running Linux that I use and remote in from my normal laptop, but I've had a lot of issues with linux working smoothly on a laptop development.
i've seen the poor quality of MacOS recently, but it's relative compared to the despair I feel with windows.
> stability has been replaced with transitional pains of a new application framework, iOS-ification of much of the system, and inconsistent behavior
I see your point but I kinda disagree. As a daily macOS user (I have a MBP for work and one for personal use), my workflow just doesn't change much (if at all) between updates. If anything, I use less third party software since Sequoia (I replaced Rectangle with native window snapping, which is good enough). Tahoe didn't change anything for me. Working on a MacBook doesn't feel less powerful than before, and everything still "just works". I don't feel like the OS gets in my way at all.
That being said, I bought an old Dell last year for dev work (primarily Linux) and I can’t believe most of the world puts up with Windows. It seems like desktop computing is an afterthought.