Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

no I think it's fuel for boiling water


Ah yes, nuclear energy, real hot, make water boil, make things happen.

You're telling me we don't have sci-fi energy harnessing capability to capture the nuclear energy itself and convert it to electricity?

It's 2025!


Steam power is no joke if you actually look at the numbers. At this scale, it lets you move energy around and convert it to electricity in fewer steps, with fewer losses, than any other strategy.


Found it kind of depressing that this seems to be the current strategy for fusion as well.

You have this insane device that produces a million degree hot ring of plasma and use it... to boil water...


We are still trying to solve the problem that we can't keep the plasma hot long enough to create fusion energy, so working on exotic conversion schemes is one step too far.

Consider also how complex these reactors already are, it makes sense to use the simplest method that we know works well.


Makes sense, but from a layman perspective it seems like introducing additional complexity and lots of inefficient, high-loss transmission steps.

We start with detached electrons moving at high speeds (plasma). We want detached electrons moving at moderate speeds (electrical current). And yet, the intermediate steps involve everything from heat, steam, large-scale mechanical forces and magnetic induction, just to get back to the electrons?

It feels more like the "pull in a 500MB framework instead of writing the function yourself" kind of simplicity.


> It feels more like the "pull in a 500MB framework instead of writing the function yourself" kind of simplicity.

Essentially yes, but it's a function that has been continuously optimised by engineers for 200 years.


Scy-fi enegry generator looks inside steam turbine


To be fair, I think we're getting something like 60% efficiency that way. Its not perfect, but it isnt as primitive as it sounds.


There are lots of ideas, like using a reverse cyclotron (a particle decelerator) to drive a turbine, or harnessing the photo-electric effect (essentially solar panels, but for x-rays).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_energy_conversion


Keep it simple, stupid.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: