Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Hate speech is not a crime, at least not in the US (thank god).

My point was that you complain about about speech being suppressed, but ignore the same when it comes to things like hate speech and DEI.

Seems like the best approach is no speech restrictions rather than banning it based on the flavor of the week politics?



My mistake for confusing hate speech directly with hate crime. Hate speech can turn a crime into a “hate crime” and that’s my mistake for conflating the two. In my original post the thought behind it was hateful speech with an incitement towards violence - either way, I can agree that speech itself shouldn’t be illegal even if hateful, and I agree with where the law is that if it calls for violence against a group it can constitute a crime.

> My point was that you complain about about speech being suppressed, but ignore the same when it comes to things like hate speech and DEI.

I think it’s very clear - the government shouldn’t be infringing on speech. Hateful or not - so long as the speech doesn’t coincide with calls to action or other things that cause said speech to become part of a crime. And even then, it’s still less about the speech - that’s not the illegal part (as you correct earlier) - it’s about the actions that may rise to the level of a crime.

Overall I still don’t know how DEI works into any of this and I’d like for you to elaborate on that part.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: